Clayface

Film Review: Clayface

Clayface has always been one of Batman’s most iconic comic book nemeses yet has only appeared in a sprinkling of lesser DC TV series against Gotham’s miserable winged one. Initially appearing in the 2002 TV series Birds of Prey (not the Margot Robbie one with the impossibly long title), he has popped up here and there in various animated outings – most notably 2004’s Batman and 1992’s Batman: The Animated Series. He also appeared in Scooby Doo and Batman (2018) and weirdly as a zombie in 2014’s Gotham series. His character has always deserved more, and finally he gets his own film here, directed by James Watkins starring Welshman Tom Rhys Harries as the titular character.

We are introduced to Matt Hagen, a friendly Hollywood actor on the cusp of greatness. Interviewed on chat shows and adorning front covers of magazines, we see him on-set receiving an Oscar nomination to the genuine delight of his peers before breaking down and tearfully talking to his dead mother backstage – ‘We did it’. That evening he goes out to local club The Target, with his long-time friend and fellow actor Corey (Joshua James). He starts dancing with the beautiful Mia Torrez (Joana Ribeiro), initially unaware that she is the girlfriend of club owner and powerful crime boss Markos Szabo (David Dencik). Hagen ignores Corey’s warnings and spends the night with her at his penthouse suite, only to wake surrounding by Szabo and his goons. What follows is one of the wince-inducing body horror scenes this side of The Substance as Szabo goes to work on the actor’s face with a knife. His face ruined and his career in tatters, Hagen turns to experimental treatment with scientist Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie) to try and reconstruct his once adored visage.

Casting was key here and Rhys Harries turned out to be the perfect choice. Clayface’s character arc required a main man at the top of his game and Rhys Harries delivers. There are many observations throughout the film – self-identity, anguish, superficiality, cancel culture, love, revenge and the transient nature of fame – and that needed a very nuanced performance. Hagen’s desperation to rebuild his life is intrinsically linked to rebuilding his face. It was crucial that we bought into Hagen’s actions, thus avoiding a pantomime, and the film’s pacing delivers this at a relatively lean 1 hour 48 (ten minutes less with credits), which is no mean feat. The ever-underrated Eddie Marsden is great as Hagen’s dicey lawyer and Joshua James gives the complex performance of a budding actor living in the shadow of his best friend while dealing with his own needs and aspirations. Szabo and Torrez are the couple from hell and, although their characters are relatively unexplored, do the job of crime lord and dame perfectly well. Corr plays the cautious scientist role, initially sceptical about using her experimental treatment on Hagen, before getting pulled along with the results and unexpected potential applications of her work.

Be warned however, Clayface is an 18 in the UK and R in the US for ‘Strong bloody violence and Gore’ and that is a warning that is worth heeding if you’re sensitive to such things. At no point does Watkins pull away from the violence – Szabo’s early knife-based destruction of Hagen’s face a particular standout, and one that would give Terrifier directors pause for thought. But it feels necessary, as the graphic nature of the violence creates an emotional link to fully understand Hagen’s subsequent actions.

It comes at a time of yet more corporate tension at DC with James Gunn and Peter Safran both leaving their executive roles after Skydance’s acquisition of Warner Brothers. Superman and Clayface have both cleared tidy profits, Supergirl deservedly bombing, but replacing Gunn and Safran with Jeremy Latcham seems an intentional move back toward family friendly superhero films, which may not incorporate a future for more adult-orientated output such as Joker, The Penguin and Clayface.

It’s a well-trodden axiom that Marvel have the best superheroes and DC the best villains, and Clayface is further proof of this. Do we really need another Superman, Batman or Wonder Woman film? Not really. DC need to dig deep into the comic book’s wonderful resource of bad guys and produce more films like this. Although with Latham at the helm, this is unfortunately looking less than likely.

Clayface is out now at cinemas.

Review by Colin Lomas

Keep up to date with all new content on Joyzine via our
Facebook | Bluesky | Instagram | Mailing List

Leave a Comment